profile

Nudge Newsletter

Why hot sauce in a grenade tastes hotter | Nudge Newsletter

Published 4 months ago • 2 min read

Associative Learning

​Read online​

I'm reading The Expectation Effect.

On page 52¹, there's a story that every marketer should read:

The surgeon John Noland Mackenzie was among the first to test a negative expectation effect in medicine.
​
Working at Baltimore's Eye, Ear and Throat Charity Hospital in the 1880s, he examined a 32-year-old woman with severe asthma and hay fever.
​
When exposed to pollen, her nose and eyes would run and her throat would itch so badly she felt she must "tear [it] out with her nails."
​
On the worst occasions she suffered hour-long sneezing fits, spent much of the summer in bed, and couldn't keep flowers in the house.
Something about the woman's descriptions led Mackenzie to question whether pollen was really the cause.
​
He acquired an artificial rose "of such exquisite workmanship that it presented a perfect counterfeit of the original," carefully wiped every leaf and petal, then revealed it from behind a screen mid-consultation.
​
Within a minute, her voice was hoarse, her nose blocked, and she had the irresistible urge to sneeze. Her nose and throat were visibly red and swollen.
Once Mackenzie revealed the rose was fake, she had to inspect it closely before she believed him. On her next visit, she buried her nose in a bunch of real roses without a single sneeze.

This story exposes associative learning.

We become conditioned to thinking a product, service (or rose) will deliver a certain output.

For example, we associate the following:

  • Expensive wine = higher quality.
  • Family-run business = more trustworthy.
  • Supermarket own-brand = lower quality.
  • A slow website = cheap.
  • A heavy product = better built.

But marketers can hack into this. Take this hot sauce from the states...

The General's Hot Sauce probably tastes hotter because it's served in a grenade.

People globally associate a grenade with explosives. Which is why hot sauce served in a grenade shell tastes spicier.

Charles Spence² writes about associative learning in Sensehacking. He explains how loud cars really do seem like they're driving faster.

One 2011 study found that participants thought a louder car was driving 10% faster than a quieter car travelling at the exact same speed.

We associate noise with speed. And grenades with power.

The General's Hot Sauce could spend thousands of pounds tracking down even hotter chillis, or they could simply put their sauce in a grenade. Both have the same effect.

What did you think of today's newsletter?

​Phill​

P.S. I've created a free psychology of pricing course. It covers everything I know about pricing. As you're a subscriber, you can get access instantly.

¹Robson, D. (2022). The expectation effect: How your mindset can transform your life. Canongate Books.

²Spence, C. (2021). Sensehacking: How to use the power of your senses for happier, healthier living. Viking.

As a behavioural science practitioner, I believe in the peak-end rule.

​Tune into Nudge | Advertise with Nudge | Unsubscribe

Nudge Newsletter

Phill Agnew

I spend 18 hours each week turning marketing psychology into readable newsletters.

Read more from Nudge Newsletter

Labour Illusion Read online I have a slightly unhinged theory that most websites lie to me. I know you're reaching for the unsubscribe button, wondering how many tin foil hats I can fit on my massive hat, but wait. I have some evidence. In 2025, most of the major LLM models made an almost identical update. Claude, ChatGPT, Gemini and many others started to show what they were thinking. What Claude told me when I asked it if websites were lying to me. According to Claude, Anthropic does this...

about 17 hours ago • 2 min read
Ibrahimovic's kids join AC Milan and Swede, 40, could stay as a coach when he FINALLY retires

Prove Your Dedication Read online Imagine your hometown football club booked Swedish legend Ibrahimovic to host a 2-hour training session with local children. That’s what 113 participants at the Stockholm School of Economics were asked to imagine in 2017¹. But there was a catch. Half were told the club spent almost no time persuading Ibrahimovic, with the manager saying: "It's fantastic that it was so easy to persuade you to come." The others were told booking Ibrahimovic took extreme...

8 days ago • 1 min read

Framing Your Food Read online Which of these would you rather eat: One Shepherd's Pie is described as: Beef shepherd's pie, tomato and pesto sauce The other is described as: Beef subtly seasoned with Espelette pepper under a rich velvety potato puree, topped with crisp parmesan cheese crumbs Two researchers ran a small study at a French cafeteria to test if these descriptions changed the perception of the food.¹ Diners were invited to eat a prix fixe lunch. A real photo of the cafeteria from...

15 days ago • 1 min read