In the early 1970s an ambitious young director released his film THX 1138.
The concept went against many of the typical Hollywood storylines at the time.
Set in a dystopian future where sex is outlawed and drug-taking is mandatory, the film was wildly different from what audiences were used to.
The film was also a massive flop.
Despite the a-list cast and big marketing budget, few watched it. The young director was discouraged and almost gave up until he read The Hero With A Thousand Faces.
Joseph Campbell's book reveals how different cultures share remarkably similar hero stories.
He suggests that the innate human experience leads all of us to prefer surprisingly similar tales. For example:
Goodies vs baddies
Coming of age
David vs goliath
Campbell encourages writers to develop new concepts on familiar and safe themes.
It's now termed the new and safe effect, or NaS effect.
The young director took this advice onboard and created a film you've probably heard of.
George Lucas isn't the first director to successfully apply NaS. In fact, marketers regularly do the same.
In 2013, researchers Shapiro and Nielsen asked dozens of participants to review hundreds of ads¹.
One group was shown the same jam ad for Druk every 50 ads.
The other group was shown almost the same ad, but with the logo moved to different corners.
All the participants preferred the jam if they'd seen it before (we prefer familiar things).
But those participants who saw slightly different versions liked it even more (we prefer new things that are familiar).
We see this in food trends.
NaS = chicken tikka, avocado on toast, matcha latte, and kombucha. No NaS = matcha milk tofu
Matcha lattes became insanely popular because they combined a new ingredient (matcha) with something safe and familiar (a latte).
Matcha milk tofu will never catch on, because both ingredients (tofu and matcha) are too new and unfamiliar.
But how can you apply this effect?
You're not developing food trends or producing Hollywood movies.
But you're probably writing headlines. Email subject lines, blog headers, and presentation titles.
In 2013² three researchers studied what made a good title.
Over several months, they posted the same meme on Reddit dozens of times but tweaked the title.
This allowed them to pinpoint which titles drove the highest engagement.
Their takeaway proved how important the NaS effect is.
A good headline is “not overly familiar, but rather familiar enough; a welcome surprise expressed in the vernacular of its intended audience.”
The takeaway is simple.
The best products, movies, headlines, and even ads combine two elements.
They're novel and new. But also familiar and safe.
Do you agree?
P.S. This newsletter is a trimmed-down version of the talk I gave at Creator Day last week. The next one is the 6th of May 2027.
It's a wonderful event and is part of a brilliant community run by my mate Mark Masters. (This isn't a paid ad; I just like the community! In fact, it's the only community I'm part of.)
NaS is a combination of two of the 85 principles you'll find in the Nudge Vaults. If you're keen to apply NaS, you should search for this distinctiveness effect and mere exposure effect in the Vaults.
In fact, Nudge Vaults subscribers can use VaultsGPT to apply these principles like this to their work:
¹Shapiro, S. A., & Nielsen, J. H. (2013). What the blind eye sees: Incidental change detection as a source of perceptual fluency. Journal of Consumer Research, 39(6), 1202–1218. ²Lakkaraju, H., McAuley, J., & Leskovec, J. (2013). What's in a name? Understanding the interplay between titles, content, and communities in social media. Proceedings of the Seventh International AAAI Conference on Weblogs and Social Media, 311–320.
As a behavioural science practitioner, I believe in the peak-end rule.
Pratfall Effect Read online A few years back I received this review. It hurt me a bit and knocked my confidence. I was desperate for listeners to leave some positive reviews so others wouldn't see it. I tried to cover it up, but other brands do the opposite. Spa Diner promotes "the worst breakfast one man on Yelp ever had". Snowbird put their 1-star review in a double-page magazine ad. The Antelope pub share their negative reviews on Facebook. This sandwich shop printed out their 1-star...
The Issue With AI Read online There's a community on Reddit where users debate if an image is AI-generated. This image was subject to fierce debate. Turns out it is AI-generated. This is an AI pizza. In the comments, most users say they'd stop visiting a restaurant that used AI in its photos. Another user shared an example of their local pizza joints doing the same. Sarno forgot to erase the Papa John's logo from their AI pizza. Reddit users hate these AI images. One commenter said: "this...
Negativity Bias Read online You'd be forgiven for thinking this ad is nonsensical. I've always liked it. The reverse psychology makes it stick in my mind. But recently I read a study which explains why it works. Negative framing. In 2025, researchers Wallach, Blair and Tanenbaum published a paper titled 'This Article Is Not for Everyone'. For the study, participants were shown one of the following slogans for a new dark roast coffee. Half saw positive framing: 'This is the coffee for you if...