Is The "New Manager Bounce" Real? | Nudge Newsletter


Do new managers give teams a "bounce"?

Read online


In sports, it's common to hear about the "new manager bounce".

It's an immediate improvement in performance following a change of manager.

Like most sporting clichés, it's made its way into the working world.

An old boss of mine justified a managerial replacement. by citing the need to quickly hit that quarter's KPIs.

But is the new manager bounce real?

One detailed study¹ on Polish football managers found that players initially ran faster and farther after a manager was fired.

But this was just a return to normal effort levels prior to the underperforming old manager.

Long-term results didn't improve.

A Norwegian study² compared NFL* teams that fired managers vs. those that hadn't.

Despite having similar performance declines, teams that kept their coaches actually recovered faster.

Those who fired the manager improved far more slowly.

Turns out, replacing a manager rarely provides lasting performance gains — Phill

P.S. This insight is taken from Colin Fisher's great book The Collective Edge.

¹Radzimiński, Ł., Chmura, P., Chmura, J., Kowalczuk, E., & Konefał, M. (2022). The effect of mid-season coach turnover on running match performance and match outcome in professional soccer players. Scientific Reports, 12(1), 1–10.

²Arnulf, J. K., Mathisen, J. E., & Hærem, T. (2012). Heroic leadership illusions in football teams: Rationality, decision making and noise-signal ratio in the firing of football managers. Leadership, 8(2), 169–185.

*Norwegian Football League, not the American National Football League.

As a behavioural science practitioner, I believe in the peak-end rule.

Tune into Nudge | Advertise with Nudge | Unsubscribe

Nudge Newsletter

I spend 18 hours each week turning marketing psychology into readable newsletters.

Read more from Nudge Newsletter

Mystery Effect Read online I submit a gas and electricity reading every month. Not because I'm diligent or disciplined. But because my supplier (Octopus Energy) nudges me to do so. Every time I leave a gas reading, they let me spin a wheel to win a potential reward. Most suppliers just ask for a reading (left). Octopus offer a chance to win (right). I've shared this before, but I haven't shared much evidence as to why it works. So, take a look at these images from a 2022 study¹.Which would...

Long-Term Goals = Success? Read online You've probably heard of the “Yale Goal Study". Here's the study. In 1953, researchers interviewed Yale’s graduating class. They asked a simple question: “Have you written down your goals for life?” Twenty years later, they tracked the same students down. And discovered something dramatic. Just 3% had written specific goals. And that 3% had built more personal wealth than the other 97% combined. It’s a perfect self-help story, with a simple lesson. Make...

Commitment Devices Read online Often we plan to do something and don't. Donating blood, going on a run, watching that webinar. We want to, but forget. This drives marketers insane. People sign up for their events—but no one comes. Katy Milkman, a brilliant professor at the Wharton School at the University of Pennsylvania, found a solution¹. She used a commitment device. Milkman and her colleagues teamed up with a large American utility firm to see if they could prompt more of the company's...