This pointless change boosted sales by 10% | Nudge Newsletter


The Decoy Effect

Read online


Adding a worthless option could increase your sales.

Take this study¹ from the University of Liechtenstein. The researchers showed a representative sample of readers these two book choices:

The vast majority of people decided to buy the $10 e-book rather than both the e-book and the hardcover.

However, the researchers then tested adding a third decoy option.

This option was pointless, offering just the hardcover for $20, yet it altered behaviour.

Now, the least popular option has become the most popular.

According to Bas Wouters², the researchers were also able to calculate that sales would increase by 10% if they added this unattractive option in real life.

Dan Ariely³ replicated this finding with his real-world study. Working with The Economist, he persuaded the majority of readers to choose the more expensive $125 Print & Web Subscription by adding a decoy Print-Only Subscription.

Hilariously, the decoy effect doesn't only boost sales.

In Predictably Irrational, Dan Ariely compared the attractiveness of two men: Tom and Jerry.

If Jerry's ugly brother was pictured next to Jerry, Tom became more attractive.

If he were pictured next to Tom, Jerry would be seen as more attractive.

Our surroundings always anchor us.

So, if you want to make your preferred choice seem more attractive, add a decoy option at the same price.

That's all for nowPhill

P.S. Did you enjoy this newsletter? Please forward it on. I spent hours researching the decoy effect and would love for more marketers to be aware of this principle.

¹Tietz M, Simons A, Weinmann M et al (2016). The decoy effect in reward-based crowdfunding: preliminary results from an online experiment. Paper presented at the 37th International Conference on Information Systems (ICIS 2016), Dublin, Ireland.

²Wouters, B., & Groen, J. (2020). Online influence: Boost your results with proven behavioral science

³Ariely, D. (2008). Predictably irrational: The hidden forces that shape our decisions. Harper.

As a behavioural science practitioner, I believe in the peak-end rule*

Tune into Nudge | Advertise with Nudge | Unsubscribe

Nudge Newsletter

I spend 18 hours each week turning marketing psychology into readable newsletters.

Read more from Nudge Newsletter

Generation Effect Read online This ad outside my local opticians sticks in my mind. "Blink if you need an eye exam." At first glance, it's bizzare. It doesn't promote the business, showcase a promotion, or entice people in. And yet, I think it's weirdly effective due to the generation effect. In 1978, researchers¹ asked participants to either read work pairs or generate missing words from cues. For example: Read condition: hot → cold Generate condition: hot → c___ Those generating answers...

Isolation Effect Read online Noah Kagan tested his book cover design by photoshopping the book onto shelves to see what stood out. The green cover isn't different, but it is distinct. In 1933, German researcher Hedwig Von Restorff¹ published a paper on memory and distinctiveness. She gave participants long lists of letter combinations to remember (e.g. JTSW, UCSM, PLST), but among them was a single number sequence: 9125. When participants returned after a distraction task, Hedwig found that...

Social Proof Read online "Window cleaning in progress" I love this board because it remembers something most marketers forget. A real photo taken on a suburban street in Houston. Cialdini proved that we're persuaded by others. In an Arizonan hotel room, he placed two messages on hotel doors designed to convince guests to reuse their towels. “Help us save the environment” = 35% towel reuse. “Most guests reuse their towels” = 44% towel reuse. We're persuaded by others' actions. So, if a...