profile

Nudge Newsletter

Over 1,000 people will ignore this email | Nudge Newsletter 🧠

Published over 1 year ago • 1 min read

Well Done! You don't follow the crowd.

Thank you for opening today’s email.

Because psychology suggests you wouldn’t.

There’s a psychological principle known as negative social proof.

Definition = if you make an unwanted behaviour seem commonplace, more people will perform the unwanted behaviour.

Few examples:

  • “Visitors steal 5 tons a year” increased wood theft at an Arizona park (Cialdini, 1984)
  • “Many miss their NHS appointments” increased no-shows (Martin, 2024)
  • “Over 1,000 people will ignore this email” should harm open rates (*ongoing study Agnew, 2024)

In 2022, BBC published an article which shouldn’t surprise you

“The Met Police practice of posting photographs of seized knives on social media could be encouraging knife-carrying, according to a new study.
​
The University of Strathclyde research also found that sharing such images risked creating ‘a culture of fear’ and ‘perpetuating negative stereotypes’”

With all the best intentions, communicators repeatedly make this mistake.

Even organisations that should be aware of consumer behaviour fail.

Take Wikipedia’s notoriously bad attempt to encourage readers to donate.

No prizes for identifying what’s wrong with this message.

So, if you’re trying to deter a certain behaviour, never make the unwanted behaviour seem commonplace.

Cheers!

Phill

Nudge Newsletter

Phill Agnew

I spend 18 hours each week turning marketing psychology into readable newsletters.

Read more from Nudge Newsletter

Pratfall Effect Read online A few years back I received this review. It hurt me a bit and knocked my confidence. I was desperate for listeners to leave some positive reviews so others wouldn't see it. I tried to cover it up, but other brands do the opposite. Spa Diner promotes "the worst breakfast one man on Yelp ever had". Snowbird put their 1-star review in a double-page magazine ad. The Antelope pub share their negative reviews on Facebook. This sandwich shop printed out their 1-star...

7 days ago • 1 min read

The Issue With AI Read online There's a community on Reddit where users debate if an image is AI-generated. This image was subject to fierce debate. Turns out it is AI-generated. This is an AI pizza. In the comments, most users say they'd stop visiting a restaurant that used AI in its photos. Another user shared an example of their local pizza joints doing the same. Sarno forgot to erase the Papa John's logo from their AI pizza. Reddit users hate these AI images. One commenter said: "this...

13 days ago • 1 min read

Negativity Bias Read online You'd be forgiven for thinking this ad is nonsensical. I've always liked it. The reverse psychology makes it stick in my mind. But recently I read a study which explains why it works. Negative framing. In 2025, researchers Wallach, Blair and Tanenbaum published a paper titled 'This Article Is Not for Everyone'. For the study, participants were shown one of the following slogans for a new dark roast coffee. Half saw positive framing: 'This is the coffee for you if...

20 days ago • 1 min read