Over 1,000 people will ignore this email | Nudge Newsletter 🧠


Well Done! You don't follow the crowd.

Thank you for opening today’s email.

Because psychology suggests you wouldn’t.

There’s a psychological principle known as negative social proof.

Definition = if you make an unwanted behaviour seem commonplace, more people will perform the unwanted behaviour.

Few examples:

  • “Visitors steal 5 tons a year” increased wood theft at an Arizona park (Cialdini, 1984)
  • “Many miss their NHS appointments” increased no-shows (Martin, 2024)
  • “Over 1,000 people will ignore this email” should harm open rates (*ongoing study Agnew, 2024)

In 2022, BBC published an article which shouldn’t surprise you

“The Met Police practice of posting photographs of seized knives on social media could be encouraging knife-carrying, according to a new study.
The University of Strathclyde research also found that sharing such images risked creating ‘a culture of fear’ and ‘perpetuating negative stereotypes’”

With all the best intentions, communicators repeatedly make this mistake.

Even organisations that should be aware of consumer behaviour fail.

Take Wikipedia’s notoriously bad attempt to encourage readers to donate.

No prizes for identifying what’s wrong with this message.

So, if you’re trying to deter a certain behaviour, never make the unwanted behaviour seem commonplace.

Cheers!

Phill

Nudge Newsletter

I spend 18 hours each week turning marketing psychology into readable newsletters.

Read more from Nudge Newsletter

The Contrast Effect Read online Rosser Reeves, an American ad executive from the 1950s, was eating lunch in Central Park. He and his colleague saw a man begging for money. It was late afternoon, but the beggar hadn't made much money. Reeves told his colleague: “I bet I can dramatically increase the amount of money that guy is raising simply by adding four words to his sign." The colleague agreed, and Reeves introduced himself to the homeless man. He explained that he knew something about...

Titles That Sell Read online Emanuel Haldeman-Julius was an incredibly wealthy book salesman. He didn't write. He resold famous literature to an American audience. Goethe and Shakespeare were printed on cheap paper and sold in big quantities. He sold more than 200 million¹ booklets, each for five cents. Emanuel Haldeman-Julius in the 1930s. Emanuel noticed that some books sold better than others. He hypothesised that buyers judge a book by its title. So, he rewrote the titles of his least...

Expense Boosts Value Read online This quote summarises one of the most overlooked marketing lessons. Rory Sutherland in Alchemy¹ This idea (that expense boosts value) is known as costly signalling. I did a silly, and simple, experiment² to prove it. I showed 200 random Brits an ad for my podcast. 50% saw only the ad. 50% saw the ad superimposed onto a billboard. The billboard signaled expense, and it made Brits 61% more likely to listen. But advertisers can push this further. Rather than just...